We read now and then an article title that reads “ the missing link found”, or “another proof for evolution”, or something similar.
Upon reviewing history, many claimed to have discovered evidence for the theory of evolution, but it turns out that these claims were false. We will examine some of these incidents below.
1. Piltdown Man (1912)
Scientist: Charles Dawson.
Claim: The “missing link” between apes and humans had been discovered.
Fraud Details: In 1912, Charles Dawson, an amateur archaeologist, claimed to have discovered skull fragments in Piltdown, England, which appeared to show a human-like cranium with an ape-like jaw. It was hailed as proof of human evolution from apes.
Exposure: In 1953, more sophisticated dating and fluorine analysis techniques revealed that the skull was a hoax — the jawbone came from an orangutan and had been artificially aged and filed to fit.
2. Haeckel’s Embryo Drawings (Late 1800s)
Scientist: Ernst Haeckel, German biologist and philosopher.
Claim: Embryos of different species (e.g., fish, reptiles, humans) look strikingly similar in early stages, suggesting common ancestry.
Fraud Details: Haeckel produced a series of embryo drawings to support his theory of “ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny” — that embryos pass through adult stages of their evolutionary ancestors. However, he exaggerated the similarities and omitted key differences.
Exposure: Other embryologists, including Wilhelm His, criticised Haeckel’s work during his lifetime. Modern science has shown that while some similarities exist, the drawings were misleading.
3. Archaeoraptor (1999)
Scientist: Stephen Czerkas, Currie, Rowe, and Xu.
Claim: A perfect transitional fossil between dinosaurs and birds.
Fraud Details “Archaeoraptor” is the informal name for a fossil from China. The team wrote an article published in National Geographic magazine in 1999, where the magazine editor claimed that the fossil was a “missing link” between birds and terrestrial theropod dinosaurs.
Exposure: Palaeontologists soon realised the fossil was a composite, and the article was retracted
4. Nebraska Man (1922).
Scientist: Harold Cook.
Claim: A supposed primitive human fossil was found in Nebraska.
Fraud Details: A single tooth was used to reconstruct an entire ape-man (“Hesperopithecus haroldcookii”), complete with illustrations in popular media showing it with primitive tools.
Exposure: Palaeontologists soon realised the fossil was a composite, and the article was retracted.
5. Orce Man (1984)
Scientist: Gibert, Agustí, and Moyà-Solà.
Claim: The earliest evidence of human presence in Europe
Fraud Details: In 1982, the first systematic excavation at Venta Micena led to the find of a skullcap fragment (VM-0) interpreted as human. VM-0 is described by Gibert, Agustí, and Moyà-Solà as the oldest fossil of Homo sp. from Eurasia; the discovery was widely publicised as the ‘Orce Man’ in the media.
Exposure: The fossil was later proven to be of a four-month-old donkey.
You’ll find more articles on evolution here.
You can find us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/StPaulCopticApologetics and YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SaintPaulCopticApologetics
